crepemyrtle: Didn't know you were making soap! Did you buy commercial lye, or drip your own? I have plans to use a combination of rosemary, sage, and lavender when I finally get around to soapmaking. I think the combination of herbs will help with the smell issues (particularly the rosemary), and all 3 have anti-bacterial qualities. Did the tallow smell eventually go away, or did it stay in the soap? And do you use some sort of rinsing agent? I don't care for the residue soap leaves on everything; I have very fine hair, so it gets weighed down. I thought of perhaps making a rinsing agent out of vinegar, scented with the same combo of rosemary, sage, and lavender. I believe the vinegar will help cut through the residue. I did try it when using soap for dishwashing (though it wasn't scented), and it helped make my glasses clearer, and left less soap scum in the rinse sink.